Double Diamond Auctions

A full service auction and appraisal company


If you are looking for a company with owners who have strong faith and integrity, please contact us today.

Founded in 2021, Todd and Alicia Natale and Garrett and Bailey Balsick strive to provide a full service auction company founded on integrity and treating buyers and sellers fairly.

We are a Christian based company and these principles follow over into our business practices. If you are looking for a company who will treat you right, Double Diamond Auctions is where you want to go. We are a full service Auction company. We will help with all aspects of the auction process. Set up, appraisals, pictures, advertising, security on sale day, collecting the money, and all other aspects of the auction. We are truly here to serve you. Todd is an experienced auctioneer with lots of knowledge of equipment and tools and Garrett brings a wealth of knowledge of antiques and digital marketing

Todd Natale

Head Auctioneer & Owner

Todd has been a fan of the auction method of marketing for many years and was given the opportunity to learn the skill in 2008 when he became a contract auctioneer for Skeeter’s Auction Service. He has since had the chance to work for several auction companies, including Ed Kovitz Auctioneers, MH Bar Auctions, Micheals Auctions, and Farmer-Stockman Auctions. Todd has donated many hours of auctioneering for local benefits throughout Colorado as well as in his home town of Toledo, Washington.
Todd believes in treating the buyer and the seller with the utmost respect, for it is because of them that the auction is possible. With a strong Christian faith, it is Todd’s goal to keep integrity as the backbone of the business.
Todd believes in family and has had his 4 children help with his auctions in some way. He and Alicia enjoy their small ranch outside of Simla and the quiet time that it brings to their lives.

Garrett Balsick

Head Appraiser & Owner

Garrett, a father of 2 girls and husband of a beautiful wife, is the 5th generation of B/K Ranch, which is a small cow/calf and hay operation just north of Calhan. He has been around auctions his entire life chasing windmills with his father and his grandfather all over the country. This created a passion for antiques and the people who collect and sell them. In 2017 Garrett and Bailey created B/K Antiques LLC which is an online antique store. They have collectively created a nationwide network of followers and fellow collectors. This network has provided him with experts of antiques in all different realms who are willing to help him find values of items he may not know about. He has bought and sold enough antiques that he is up to date on the market in a majority of the “farmtiques” we will find in this area. Garrett also brings a wealth of business and marketing knowledge that will benefit the clients of Double Diamond Auctions.
Family, business, ranching, auctions, and antiques are fun. But being a follower of Jesus and a Christian is the most important value in Garrett’s life. This business is to steward the resources and gifts given to the clients and Double Diamond Auctions with exceptional service.

Alicia Natale

Head Clerk

Alicia was raised going to auctions with her dad and especially loved meeting the auctioneers. She loves relaying stories about how the auctioneers loved her and treated her so kindly. Some things never change. When Todd became an auctioneer, she joined right in and was put to work as a clerk and learning to work in the office. She is one of the best auction clerks around. Alicia has offered her talent as a bid spotter and finds great fun in that.
Alicia is very committed to making sure that everything goes correctly during a sale and always does so with honesty, grit, and compassion. She is truly the force behind the sale that makes it a success.

Visit us at our next auction!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!